The Chilling Case of the Circleville Letter Writer - [UNSOLVED?] For nearly two decades, an anonymous letter writer terrorizes the small town of Circleville, Ohio, by sending threatening letters that expose alleged secrets about neighbors and friends. The anonymous writer targeted a bus driver named Mary Gillispie — at first. But letters soon targeted other Circleville residents. Decades later, can the identity of the mysterious writer be cracked? Paul Freshour died June 28, 2012, at age 70, sti